A trade idea making the rounds this offseason imagines a bold swap between the Atlanta Braves and the Chicago Cubs. In this scenario, Chicago sends versatile infielder Nico Hoerner to Atlanta, while the Braves move hard-throwing reliever Robert Suarez to the Cubs to fix Chicago’s late-inning problem.It is not an official offer, but the structure lines up cleanly with what both teams need right now. Atlanta would be turning bullpen depth into everyday infield stability. Chicago would be turning infield depth into a true ninth-inning stopper. Both players are in their primes and under multi-year control, which makes the idea more than a short-term gamble.

A simple framework for a one-for-one blockbuster

The core of the deal is straightforward.

Atlanta Braves receive

• Nico Hoerner (SS/2B, under control through at least 2027 with club options after)

Chicago Cubs receive

• Robert Suarez (RHP, under a three-year, $45 million deal running through 2028)Atlanta would be exchanging a premium reliever for an everyday middle infielder who can handle multiple spots. Chicago would be doing the opposite: sacrificing a position player to lock down the back end of the bullpen for several seasons.

Why Nico Hoerner makes sense for Atlanta Braves’ infield

Atlanta Braves’ plans up the middle changed when Ha-Seong Kim suffered a torn tendon in his right middle finger that could sideline him for four to five months. Even with Dansby Swanson on the roster, that injury opens a real gap at either shortstop or second base.Nico Hoerner fits as an immediate plug-in option. Over his career he has logged more than 1,000 innings at shortstop and nearly 800 at second base, giving Atlanta flexibility without forcing a defensive downgrade.Offensively, he offers a different look from a power-heavy lineup. In 2025 he played 156 games with a .297 batting average, strong on-base skills, and 31 steals. He does not rely on home runs, but he puts the ball in play and pressures defenses.

Hoerner’s 2025 season at a glance

That profile slots neatly alongside hitters like Ronald Acuña Jr., Matt Olson, and Austin Riley. He lengthens the top of the order with contact, speed, and reliable defense rather than adding more swing-and-miss power.

Why Robert Suarez answers Chicago Cubs’ bullpen question

Chicago Cubs’ biggest roster uncertainty is the ninth inning. A closer-by-committee approach has worked in stretches but lacks a single trusted finisher.Robert Suarez brings that role with recent proof. In 2025 he recorded 40 saves with a 2.97 ERA and a 0.90 WHIP over 63.2 innings. Across 2024 and 2025 he piled up 76 saves, more than any pitcher in that span. His combination of velocity, strikeouts, and control is built for high-leverage work.

Suarez’s 2025 profile

At 29 years old and under contract through 2028, he would give Chicago both immediate stability and multi-year certainty at the back of the bullpen.

Nico Hoerner vs Robert Suarez: Age, control, and playing style comparison

Nico Hoerner

• Age: 28 • Positions: shortstop and second base • Team control: through at least 2027, with club options after • Style: contact hitter, strong on-base skills, plus defender, impact baserunner

Robert Suarez

• Age: 29 • Position: late-inning reliever/closer • Contract: three years, $45 million, fully guaranteed • Style: power fastball, swing-and-miss slider, high strikeout rate, low walk rateNeither side is trading a rental. Both would be moving a core-age player with several years of control left.

What each team gains and gives up

Atlanta Braves’ side of the swap

Gains • A versatile everyday infielder who can cover shortstop and second • A contact and speed threat near the top of the lineup • Defensive stability in the middle infield while Kim is sidelinedLoss • A high-end reliever who could anchor late innings or be moved later for other needsAtlanta can soften that blow because it still has established relief options, including closer Raisel Iglesias.

Chicago Cubs’ side of the swap

Gains • A proven closer who immediately settles the ninth inning • Long-term control of a high-leverage arm through 2028 • A valuable bullpen piece that could also be moved later if neededLoss • A reliable, controllable middle infielderChicago can point to internal options such as James Triantos and other depth pieces to help cover second base if Hoerner is moved.

Advantages and risks for both clubs

Pros for Atlanta Braves

• Fixes an infield hole created by Kim’s injury without a stopgap move • Adds a high-contact bat that complements the existing core • Improves defensive flexibility up the middle

Cons for Atlanta

• Removes a premium bullpen arm • Could create crowding later if Kim returns and everyone is healthy

Pros for Chicago Cubs

• Turns a bullpen question mark into a strength • Secures a closer for several seasons, not just one run • Creates flexibility to reshape the infield mix

Cons for Chicago

• Gives up a multi-position everyday player • Takes on the added injury risk that always comes with pitchers

Who comes out ahead?

The trade is balanced, but the edge tilts slightly toward Atlanta. The Braves would be converting excess relief value into an everyday, two-way infielder at a moment when they have a clear positional need. Chicago would get a major bullpen upgrade, but it would be parting with a controllable position player to do it.If the Cubs are confident their in-house infield options can replace most of Hoerner’s production, the deal makes strong sense for them as well. If not, the opportunity cost becomes heavier on Chicago’s side.Also read: MLB trade rumors: Houston Astros potentially eyeing $7,725,000 Cleveland Guardians star in stellar win-now move ahead of deadlineThis idea works because it targets specific weaknesses rather than chasing star power for its own sake. Atlanta shores up the middle of the diamond during an injury window. Chicago locks down the final three outs of close games.If it ever moved from rumor to reality, it would be a classic win-now exchange: an everyday infielder for a shutdown closer, each filling a gap the other team cannot easily solve internally.